| FlazX | Browse Computer Book | Community Board | Links | Blog | Login |
|
ASP.NET by Example Google Search |
User review For beginners. Steven A. Smith, ASP.NET by Example (Que, 2002) It's been five years since the release of ASP.NET by Example, so if you're already well-versed in ASP.NET, this probably isn't the book for you. I, on the other hand, know nothing about ASP.NET, and picked it up as an introductory tome. (If you do so, you should have at least a decent background in either VB.NET or C#, the two languages Smith alternates between for his code-behind pages.) As someone coming into ASP.NET brand-new, I found it well worth reading, informative, and easy to understand. Of course, some stuff has changed in the intervening years, but enough has stayed the same so most of the book will still be useful to the ASP.NET noob. A good place for beginners to start. **** User review Sloppy editing I bought this book recently to learn ASP.NET and feel I have mainly wasted my money. In the main the author simply has not put himself into the place of the newbie he aims the book at. Rather than give opinions, let me quote specific examples from an early chapter. Listing 4.1 gives code to be added to the page_load method. When you try to run it it doesn't work. You find out 3 pages later that you should have added a group of `using` statements. It would have been easy to add these lines to the snippet, or at least give a forward reference to them. In the same snippet you're invited to open a database named `pubs` (Publications) The following snippets perform various functions on this database. But this is not a standard database, and you're given no details of how it's put together so you can mock up your own in Access or whatever. I advise against this book. User review Landfill I too purchased ASP.NET by example and I feel strongly about how terrible I think it is. The positive reviews may have been written by the Authors or their friends. I feel that this book has been slapped together quickly in order to sell books rather than to impart knowledge. Never before have I seen a book with so many glaring errors. The website of examples was not even responding when I tried to access it. Then when it was back online, the same errors were in the example code as the book. For example Chapter 9 (Using ASP.NET User Controls) is missing the fundamental InitializeComponent() and all of the related constructor methods that are required for the software to compile and run. I agree with the reviewer who mentioned that this book would do more harm than good. Perhaps a second edition, with closer editing, would be better This book is a concise and incomplete reference of ASP.NET, but that appears to have been author's intent. It's well written, well organized and easy to understand. I think the intended audience, which is a beginner-to-intermediate Web developer, will find it useful. The author makes an assumption that the reader is familiar with HTML, XML, VB or C#, and knows how to use Visual Studio.NET. DO NOT buy this book if you studying for Microsoft Certification exam/s, it's not intended for that purpose. Other books on ASP.NET |
Google Talk : admin-at-flazx-dot-us